Judge overturns decision on Pennsylvania water pollution

In an unusual move, a federal judge has overturned a US$4.24 million jury award and has ordered a new trial in the case of two Pennsylvania families who alleged that their water had been polluted by hydraulic fracturing being carried out by Marcellus shale driller Cabot Oil & Gas.

Magistrate Judge Martin Carlson said that the evidence presented in last year's trial in Scranton was “spare, sometimes contradictory, frequently rebutted by other scientific expert testimony, and relied in some measure upon tenuous inferences”. The plaintiffs are from the community of Dimock, Pennsylvania.

Carlson also pointed to what he said were many “weaknesses” in the case, and “serious and troubling irregularities in the testimony and presentation of the plaintiffs' case – including repeated and regrettable missteps by counsel in the jury's presence”.

Because of this, he said he must strike down the award by the eight-member jury against the gas driller and he ordered a new trial. “We do not take this step lightly, and we recognise the significance of voiding the judgment of a panel of jurors who sat through nearly three weeks of trial and reached a unanimous verdict,” he wrote.

The case became well-publicised, and was featured prominently in the anti-fracking documentary “Gasland”, which was released in 2010.

Scott Ely and Monica Marta-Ely and Ray and Victoria Hubert sued Cabot in 2009 claiming that the company's gas drilling activity had polluted their water wells. But Cabot has maintained that its drilling was not the cause of the elevated methane levels in the wells in the northeastern Pennsylvania village.

Initially, there were over 40 plaintiffs, but the others settled with Cabot out of court. Tests have shown that the wells did contain high levels of methane but no chemicals associated with fracking fluid.

“Cabot is pleased with Judge Carlson's decision to vacate the verdict and the award in its entirety,” Cabot spokesman George Stark told media. “Cabot felt confident that once a thorough review of the overwhelming scientific evidence and a full legal analysis of the conduct of the plaintiff's counsel was conducted, the flaws in the verdict would be understood.”

This NewsBase commentary is from our UOGM publication. To sign up for your free trial, click this link: http://newsbase.com/publications/unconventional-oil-gas

Read more NewsBase top stories via this link: http://bit.ly/2h95NUx

Connect with NewsBase on https://www.linkedin.com/company/newsbase

New service from OilVoice
Trip Shepherd is for companies who need to track their staff in areas of risk.
It's free to use, so we invite you to try it.

Visit source site


OilgasPennsylvaniaUSAOil & gas USA

More items from newsbase

Petronas considering abandoned Shell site for Pacific NorthWest LNG

Malaysia's Petronas is considering building its stalled Pacific NorthWest LNG export facility at the site of an abandoned Royal Dutch Shell LNG project in British Columbia, Canada. In a March 31 interview quoted in international media, Petronas' CEO, Wan Zulkiflee Wan Ariffin, said Shell's Ridley I ...

NewsBase Staff - NewsBase

Posted 3 years agoOpinion > PETRONASLNGCanada

Ineos agrees deal for Forties Pipeline System

Ineos has agreed to pay up to US$250 million for BP's Forties Pipeline System (FPS) and associated Kinneil Terminal in the UK North Sea. The deal will see Ineos assume responsibility for transporting around 40% of the UK's oil and gas production, the firm said on April 3. Ineos will pay US$125 mil ...

NewsBase Staff - NewsBase

Posted 3 years agoOpinion > PipelinesUK North Sea

HNA buys 51% of Glencore storage, logistics business

Commodities trader Glencore has sold a 51% share of its oil product storage and logistics business to China's HNA Innovation Finance for US$775 million in cash. The deal marks the inauguration of the Chinese firm, with the agreement being signed at the foundation ceremony for the new company on Marc ...

NewsBase Staff - NewsBase

Posted 3 years agoPress > GlencoreChinaOil

Rosneft and LUKoil launch drilling in the Arctic

Russian oil rivals Rosneft and LUKoil are preparing to launch drilling work within days at the northern tip of the Taimyr Peninsula. Recent years have seen Russia's two largest oil producers jostle for supremacy in the underexplored region, known for its extreme weather and lack of infrastructure. ...

NewsBase Staff - NewsBase

Posted 3 years agoOpinion > RussiaRosneftLUKOIL +1

At the cutting edge of laser technology

Laser drilling has long been touted as the industry's next great leap, but Ros Davidson explores whether this futuristic technology is set to remain just that Within just a few years, high-powered lasers may be used for slicing through rock – like a knife through butter – deep underground during co ...

NewsBase Staff - NewsBase

Posted 3 years agoOpinion > lasers
All posts from newsbase