Opinion

Fine: No Such Thing As 'Free Trade' With OPEC as a Cartel


Among some speakers at the 2018 Four Corners Oil and Gas Conference last month in Farmington there were evasive positions on the future of OPEC. Also, previous online or media positions of “free trade” were muted to be popular with the oil, gas and equipment operators who made up those in attendance.  

There is no “free trade” with OPEC as a cartel, either with assigned member production quotas or with the current maximization of revenue strategy led by Saudi Arabia. If you hear free traders saddling up with current higher prices and OPEC, run for cover.  

On Thanksgiving 2014, OPEC and Saudi Arabia refused to reduce oil production volume and entered a market share offensive against non-OPEC high cost oil producers in shale and tight sands.   

This was a glut, or oversupply, of world oil but it was a chance to put San Juan oil just then — with rising production in the Gallup Sand — out of business. This was only reversed through the Algiers Meeting and agreement among OPEC members by cartel anti-free trade supply and demand manipulation.  

President Trump captured this with his position that something was “artificial” about the price and supply of OPEC oil. Internal changes in the ruling House of Saudi Arabia, coupled with its power over OPEC, raised the price of world oil at least temporarily within the historic cycle of the industry.

Some Republicans oppose Trump and published or spoke against his opposition to OPEC. which is also connected to higher oil prices for consumers who might be voters. OPEC members had no problem with a hypocritical response to let the market work. Not only is there no free market making oil prices, but oil and gas operators do not make markets any longer. Commodity traders have replaced them since the 1980s.  

Only three years ago, when OPEC/Saudi Arabia had deviated from its role of supporting the world price of oil through supply volume strategy, Harold Hamm of Continental Resources called for smashing OPEC to protect independent and non-super major producers in New Mexico, Oklahoma, Texas and North Dakota. 

At the Expo, this writer traced current OPEC oil price support to the fall of Venezuela as a producer. 

Less Venezuela barrels in OPEC production protects other members, and now, Russia, from real cutbacks. Among American conservatives who believe there are free markets for oil, very little understanding of world petroleum economics and history exists.

What happens to OPEC supply and demand management when Saudi Aramco floats its shares on stock markets and reached its target of an intake of 100 billion dollars? Are New Mexico and Southwest producers preparing planning price scenarios similar to world producers for oil prices next year or in 2020? What would Washington do in a second downturn with the oil prices “awry" again?  

In a free trade world, nothing.

On natural gas prices that afternoon, there was a sense of how low the San Juan discount to Cushing could go and adaptation in taking some producing gas wells out of production.

Late that afternoon, after New Mexico Secretary of Energy Ken McQueen spoke of his work on the Governor's Initiative of cost-cutting via state regulatory access and permitting on Federal land, I concluded that the San Juan Basin still has too much natural gas too fail. 

And what happened to the big banks 10 years ago?  

And General Motors?  

Dr. Daniel Fine is the associate director of New Mexico Tech's Center for Energy Policy and the State of New Mexico Natural Gas Export Coordinator. The opinions expressed are his own.



New service from OilVoice
Trip Shepherd is for companies who need to track their staff in areas of risk.
It's free to use, so we invite you to try it.

Visit source site

https://daily-times.com/story/money/industries/oil...

Kingdom of Saudi ArabiaSaudi ArabiasaudiSaudi Arabia OilSaudi AramcoNon-OPECNon-OPEC ProductionOPECEnergy Dominanceenergy securityEnergy IndependenceEnergyAmerica FirstDr. Daniel FinePresident TrumpDonald Trumpmoneyoil & moneyBusiness newslatest oil and gas newsnewsoil and gas industry newsoil and gas newsoil newsweekly news updateweekly oil newsWorld NewsFree TradeFair TradeFreetradeNorth American Free Trade AgreementOil TradersTradeUnfair Tradeglobal energy tradeOil pricesnatural gasCrude Oil ProductionOil producersoil productionGeopolticsForeign affairsForeign policyEnergy policyGeopoliticspoliticsPolitical RiskDelaware BasinConflictPermian BasinPermianBakkenBakken crudeMarcellus ShaleMarcellusSan Juan BasinOhio ShaleNorth DakotaTexas Crude OilTexasTexas Oil and GasTexas PanhandleRepublicansrepublicanShaleUnited StatesEagle Ford ShaleCongressmidstreamPipelinesExploration and Production

More items from wfine94268


Oil bust could spur natural gas turnaround in San Juan Basin

If Merrion and key industry analysts are correct, there might be a silver lining in the oil crash caused by the coronavirus pandemic — it could end up helping northwestern New Mexico natural gas producers and even give a lift to state revenue in a time of crisis. The potential upside: The drop in ...

Will Fine


Posted 22 days agoLink > San Juan Basinnatural gasoil bust +36

Massive revenue shortfall in new state forecasts

The last time state economists released revenue forecasts, New Mexico had a massive oil boom with no end in sight. Those same economists released dire revenue projections on Wednesday, suggesting New Mexico could take in between $1.7 billion and $2.4 billion less than originally expected during t ...

Will Fine


Posted 1 month agoLink > Santa FeSANTAFENewMexico +58

New Mexico watching as Texas considers limits on oil production

Laws governing oil production in New Mexico stem from the Oil and Gas Act of 1935, which, among many other things, suggests the state can impose statewide caps on oil production, as well as more explicitly allowing it to cap output at specific reservoirs or “pools” of oil to “prevent waste.” If p ...

Will Fine


Posted 2 months agoLink > Dr. Daniel FineFarmington New MexicoGovernor of New Mexico +54

Dr. Daniel Fine & T Greg Merrion on the OIL PRICE WAR and U.S. collapse

Interview with Oil and Gas Expert Dr. Daniel Fine with T.Greg Merrion of Merrion Oil D r. Daniel Fine and T. Greg Merrion of Merrion Oil are experts in their fields.  Dr. Fine raises the fact the oil market was manipulated and explains just how it was done.  T Greg gives an acrual account of from ...

Will Fine


Posted 2 months agoOpinion > oil newsBusinessNewsBusiness news +44

Trump promises oil, gas industry assistance a day after WTI traded negative

Natural gas prices may increase Reducing oil production may have some positive impact on the San Juan Basin. Because the Permian Basin has been producing a surplus of natural gas, and there is no way to send all the natural gas to markets, the San Juan Basin natural gas prices have reached histor ...

Will Fine


Posted 2 months agoLink > Dr. Daniel FineFarmington New MexicoGovernor of New Mexico +27
All posts from wfine94268