Opinion

Dr. Daniel Fine: NAFTA, natural gas and the San Juan Basin


The North American Free Trade Agreement is now in a final stage with the U.S. team looking over the “energy chapter,” which has been approved by Canada and Mexico. The Administration's position, with a revisionist-protectionist core, offers President Trump a withdrawal-from-NAFTA option, at least a tactical move to shake up Canada and Mexico in the interest of American merchandise and agricultural exports. However, not much is known from the inside on plans for natural gas exports to Mexico. 

In 1992, the beginning of NAFTA, Mexico's oil and gas industry was government owned and operated so it fell outside a free trade agreement. Today, Mexico permits private capital to build, own and operate oil and gas exploration, production and transportation (pipelines) under its Energy Reform Law. This admits natural gas into the NAFTA framework. Nearly $6 billion of Southwest natural gas was sold (exported) to Mexico last year. Mexico imports 53 percent of its natural gas from the United States – with 60 percent on track. Needless to say, Mexico is dependent on American natural gas for its power generation.

Texas natural gas pipeline entry points dominate the trade, while the Delaware and the San Juan basins are next as business and strategic sources. The Mancos Shale natural gas below the Four Corners must access the expanding Mexican market in any revision of NAFTA terms. The Trump Administration's understanding of American natural gas trade with Mexico should include regional economic integration. Energy is required for Mexican industrial growth, and Mexico has constructed the pipelines on its side border to receive and transport natural gas from the Permian and the San Juan Basin.  

NAFTA revised should make natural gas exports from the U.S. Southwest a natural resource exemption from narrow foreign trade objectives. Natural gas reserves in the Southwest can be accessible to Mexican importers if pipelines to cross-border points attract American investment long-term. NAFTA changes would create risk disincentives.

U.S. NAFTA negotiations can be aligned with the Trump-Zinke energy policy of world domination if the export “New Mexican natural gas” is designated a “win – win.”  If the Mexican market for American natural gas is lost, New Mexican natural gas would be mostly “stranded” without offset storage; and, it would push back on the Permian with an oil-only reality as the output of gas from Pennsylvania and Ohio output expands.

Unless Texas and New York media understand the history behind the oil price collapse history of 2014-2016 the industry and public will be compelled to repeat that history soon. Oil prices are coupled into a “bubble”; or worse – speculation in a “coin” which exists as a product of computer software. Is Bitcoin speculation infecting the value of oil in commodity trading at least momentarily? Will hedging create a trade? With New Mexico oil production over 500,000 barrels per day (323,000 four years ago), the coming 30 days in Santa Fe (Legislative Session) should see a Democratic Party state budget expansion or plain spending offensive which would mirror 2018 primaries and general election conflict between progressives and centrists.

There is no threat from off-shore (Atlantic and Pacific Ocean) to New Mexican oil and gas development. President Trump is right to remove off-shore prohibitions, but now the market takes over. The cost of San Juan Basin natural gas is 80 percent less than exploration and production 50 miles out in North Carolina's Atlantic Ocean. Three or four dimensional seismic investments—yes; production—no; not as long as there is economic shale natural gas on-shore in New Mexico and the Southwest.

Daniel Fine is the associate director of New Mexico Tech's Center for Energy Policy. The opinions expressed are his own.



New service from OilVoice
Trip Shepherd is for companies who need to track their staff in areas of risk.
It's free to use, so we invite you to try it.

Visit source site

daily-times.com/story/money/business/2018/01/28/fi...

NAFTACanadaMexicoFreetradeIldefonso Guajardo VillarrealRobert Lighthizerchrystia freelandnatural gasPermianDelaware BasinSan Juan BasinDr. Daniel FineBakkenMarcellusupstreammidstreamdownstreamNew MexicoTexasOklahomacoloradoWyomingTrumpDonald TrumpPresident TrumpWhite HouseOil and GaspetroleumGeopoliticsForeign policyAmerica FirstEnergy DominanceBusiness news

More items from wfine94268


Expert Dan Fine discusses future of oil, natural gas amid low prices and the coronavirus

(Photo: Augusta Liddic/The Daily Times)AZTEC — Two tweets sent by President Donald Trump on the morning of April 2 spurred optimism for an oil industry hit hard by a flood of oil from Saudi Arabia and Russia, driving down the price. (Photo: Twitter screengrab)Fine said Russia, which has been frus ...

Will Fine


Posted 4 days agoLink > NewMexicogeopoliticalGeopolitics +66

Special lecture on the Oil Price War with Dr. Daniel Fine rescheduled for this Thursday 4/2

News Breaking Announcement from Dr. Fine--> My entire lecture is this upcoming THURSDAY APRIL 2 “ENERGY ELECTION 2020" has been moved to a Zoom conference instead from 10AM to 11:15AM ! To get on the ZOOM conference call -> 505 566 3702 and ask for Cecilia! or email cgunnell@4cornersed.com You ...

Will Fine


    US 02 Apr 2020


Posted 9 days agoEvent > durangoFarmington New Mexicocolorado +57

San Juan Basin on verge of collapse

With natural gas prices plummeting alongside oil prices, industry leaders say producers in the San Juan Basin in northwestern New Mexico could soon be forced to shut thousands of wells. That translates into less than $1 per Mcf for producers on New Mexico's side of the basin, given the additional ...

Will Fine


Posted 12 days agoLink > SanJuanBasinNewMexicoAlbuquerque +1

Oil and gas industry faces huge loss

BY KEVIN ROBINSON-AVILA AND DAN BOYD / ALBUQUERQUE JOURNAL STAFF WRITERS Published: Thursday, March 19th, 2020 at 5:04pm Updated: Thursday, March 19th, 2020 at 9:55pm " Copyright © 2020 Albuquerque Journal With oil prices plunging to their lowest level in 22 years, state legislators are proje ...

Will Fine


Posted 17 days agoOpinion > Farmington New MexicoDelaware BasinWest Texas Delaware Basin USA +63

Special lecture on the Oil Price War with Dr. Daniel Fine

You are invited to a special lecture with premiere energy and geopolitical analyst Dr. Daniel Fine ! I will be lecturing on 1) Energy Election 2020: Second Term Trump or Alternative 2) U.S Energy Domination and Trump: Export or Else 3) Gas and Oil under the Alternative: Climate Control and Taxation ...

Will Fine


Farmington   NM   US 30 Mar 2020


Posted 23 days agoEvent > oil priceoil price collapseOil prices +57
All posts from wfine94268